Ikhtilaf should not be made public. Aap log please personal messages pe debate karen, na ke public forum pe. Hamarey har ikhtilaaf ko dushman exploit kar sakta hay.
At Moderator:
Please ye ikhtilaafi debate delete kar dein, Shia-Shia ikhtilaaf ki public forum pe koi gunjaish nai honi chahye

Shia ko apni Jaan ki amaan chahyay magar is qeemat per nahi k apni pehchaan Peoples party, tahir ul Qadri, ya Imran Khan jaisay Munafiq ya Qatilo k sath karwaye. Agar Dunya k samnay SHia ka Image yay ho k wo Munafiqo or Qatilo ko support karain gae, tou is se bahtar hai tamam SHIA shahadat ki arzoo karain, Yay Karbala ki sada ha, jo TBUM ka mission

Phir humay huq nahi banta k Imam Hussain per fakhar karain k unho nay Qillat e Ansaar k bawajood Yazeed k samnay sir nahi jhukaya, or humay Huq nahi banta k Imam Khomeini per fakhar karain jinho nay Nizaam e Wilayat k liay pori duniya k Dushmani mool lay li or 2,50,000 Shia ka khoon paish kia

Hizbullah Ki pehchaan Muqawmat (Resistance) se hai, Hizbullah Siyasi jama'at nahi jis ka kam intikhabaat may hisa layna ho, Hasan Nasrullah ka fakhar Muti e Rehber hona hai,

Jab hum kisi Munafiq ya Qatil Party se alliance karain gae tou humay fiker karni chahyay k humara Tashakhus or pechan wahi khatam ho jae ge

Brother Shuja, sorry to say but this is not the way to react, your harsh attitude towards a big Scholar is not in favor of Shia's and simply not acceptable by anyone. We must show respect for all the scholars even if we disagree with their point of view

Brother Shuja, gaur karen: Imam ne Dunya ki Badtareen Party (Rastakhez) bhi band karwa di aur Dunya ki sab se Behtareen Party (Hezb-e-Jamhuri-e-Islami) bhi Band karwa di. Ab aap bataen, Imam ke is Amal se hum kia Usul nikal sakte hain? Hezbollah Party nahi, Resistance group hai. Jabke PARTY, Western Model hai.

Dusri taraf se, Inqilab ki Kamyabi ke fauran baad Hizb-e-Jamhuri-e-Islami bani. Is Hizb ke Baani Rahber (Ayt.Khamenei), Shaheed Beheshti, Shaheed Bahonar aur ehem ehem Shaksiyat shamil the. Imam Khomeini ne is Party ko band karwadiya.....

Brother Shuja, Mei aap ko Imam Khomeini ki Misal deta hu. SHAH ne Inqilab se kuch saal pehle Hizb-e-Rastaakhez banai thi aur yeh Qanun banaya tha ke Tamaam Iranians ko is Hizb (Party) ki Membership ikhtiyar karni hogi. Imam Khomeini ne Fatwa diya ke is Party mein Membership lena HARAAM hai. Dusri taraf se....

Brother, Amali Maidan mein aane ka matlab Qaum ka Shaoor Barhana, un ko Aagah karna, Bedar Karna, aur isi ka naam Bedari hai. Tehreek-e-Bedari sirf chand mahino pehle shuru nahi hui, yeh Tehreek usi waqt se hoti hai jab ek Shaheed Mutahhari jesa Muballig apni Tableegh ka Aagaz karta hai. Isi ko Tehreek-e-Bedari kehte hain

Brother Shuja, Amali taur par Maidan mein aane ka matlab yeh nahi ke Hukumat se Mutalibat karen, Saalo se Mutalibat hi kiye jarahe hain aur koi Farq, balke Zara sa bhi farq nahi parha Tashayyo par Zulm ke hawale se. Allama Iqbal farmate hain ke SAWAL (Maagna) KARNE SE EK FARD KI AUR EK QAUM KI SHAKSIYAT NABUD HOJATI HAI.

Brother, Jab Hukumat Gungi aur Behri ho, to Ehtejaj un maqaamat par kiya jaata hai jahan se Hukumat par Larza tari hosake. Governor House jese maqaamat par Protest karne se hukumat ko koi farq hi nahi parta kyunke woh ap ki baatein sun hi nahi rahi kyunke behri hai.

Brother Shuja, Kia Ap bata sakte hai ke kia hua tha Lahore Airport par? Aap ke mutabiq kia hua tha par? Agar ap ye kehna chah rahe hain ke TBUM ne tashaddud kiya ya tha to nahi, yeh khabar galat hai. Mei khud waha par hi tha. Pur Aman ehtejaj hi hua tha.

Last question Agar Election hi masail ka hal hai to phir imam Khominie ko bhi election kay zari say koshish karni chahya thi, laikan app nay pori parliment ko jo kay 90% shia thi kiyon giraya or Inqilab lay?

PLz tell me the answers of these questions
Kia hum election kay zari Pakistan main Islami System la saktay?
Please tell me what is the way?
aphi parliment main appox 30 shia mojood hain or sab say zida mar shia ko kiyon par rahi hay?
Agar election kay zari hamray nominday parliment main pohnch bhi jatay hain to ki tabli aay gi?

Hezbollalah koi siysasi party nahi hai, wo aik tehrik hai jo kay inqlab e Islami kay smarat main say hai,or Hezbollah nay kabhi Lebnon main election nahi lara kiyon kay un ka maqsad Islami system ko pori dunya main lana hay,Hezbollah Raha e Imam hussain A.S par chal rahi hay,

and Yeh bat wazhiha hai kay app jab bhi aham posts (like airport etc) kay qareeb dharna dain gay to lazmi hay kay government tashadood par utaray gi,or agar app nay sirf dharnay Governor house kay samany hi denay hai to Awam tak apna paigam kisay pohncghain gay.

Brother Shujahassan Sirf lahore main nahi balkay app ko shaid yad ho karachi main bhi aik do jaga par tashadood howa or dharna hatanay ki koshish ki gai thi or log zakhmi bhi howay thay, laikan wo log TBUM kay nahi tahya, TBUM koi party nahi yeh baidari or shaoor logon ko denay ka system hai,

Bhai jaan Tarbiyat ne dikha dia k kon Kitne pani me hai, Sirf Tehzeeb ke daere me reh kar hi kaam kia jasakta hai, sakhti Fight or dandai hal nahi hain is masle ka,
Pur amn ehtijaj ehem hai, jo ke kia jaraha hai

Brother Hani 2 bare dharne jo quetta k lie die gae un me SUC or MWM ke tehet hone wale dharno me koi bhi bad nazmi nahi hoi, dusre dharne me lahore me sab jaghun per mamlaat theek rahe sirf, lahore airport per hi masla hoa, kio?????
is ka jawab hai kisi k pas?? wo kon log the???
TBUM ko follow karne wale the wo log, is bare me kia jawab hai ????

Amali tor per medan me ana zaroori hai, sirf jalse joloos kardene se kuch nahi hoga,
Qaum me Shahoor bedar karna zaroori hai, wo josh dilane se peda nahi hoga, balke un per working karni hogi,

hamare samne sab se achi misaal Hizbullah ki hai, us ne usi corrupt system me rehte hoe us system ko theek kia or apna loha manwaya, hamen bhi unhi ki rah per amal karna hoga, bayan dene se ya musallah jiddo jahad se kuch nahi hoga, Rahbar Sayyed Ali Khamenei ko follow karna hoga, un ke ehkamat per amal karna hoga

well said Hani bhai.....Sb sa bara mujreem wo nai jo damaky karty hy .....Quran ke Roo sa wo bary mojreem hy jo planning karty hy aur in mojreemeen ko palty hy ....ya ajaab hy ke hm ause bary mojreem hokomat sa motaliba karty hy

Masha Allah...Geo

Sirf KARBALA hi in masaail ka hal hai.Inqilab ki Theory Karbala mein hai. Jab tak hum is Faasid System se Raazi hain tab tak koi Tabdeeli ka aana mumkin nahi.Pehli condition Inqilab ki yeh hai ke Log is System se NaRizaayati ka izhaar karen,phir aage koi baat barhegi.Hum sirf Hukumat ki tabdeeli chahte hai,na System ki,yani hum Raazi hain System se

Brother, Insaf Us Hukumat se maangna jo khud faasid hai aur jo khud in Killings mein shareek hai, yeh KHUDI ko khatam kardeti hai. Baat sirf Hukumat ki nahi, System ki baat hai. Khud System faasid hai. Na Imam Hussain (as) ne Yazeediyat ke System se Insaaf maanga aur na hi Imam Khomeini (ra) ne Baadshahat ke System se Insaf maanga...

Dear Hani ap k pas koi behtar solution hai kia?
Shia k pas hukoomat nahi to wo kese amal karega,
Kahin Demand, or Kahin Hat Dharmi se baat karni hogi, bheek nahi mangi jarahi, insaaf karne ko kaha ja raha hai, insaaf mangna apni khudi ko khatam karna nahi hai,
Len aen aap apna koi hukumran jo insaaf de de !!!!

Allama Iqbal says, ''Sawaal (maangna/gadaai) karne se Ek Fard ki Aur Ek Millat ki KHUDI (Shaksiyat/Tashakkhus) Khatm hojaati hai.'' Kaash hum ne Iqbal ki Nidaa hi sun li hoti to aaj hum Hukumat se Sawaal karne ke bajaae, Koi Iqdam karahe hote. Shayad yeh Mutalibaat maan bhi liye jaae, lekin Millat ki KHUDI to barbaad hogai!